Even without being directly tied to The Big Bang Theory, there’s an incredibly satisfying reason for why fans should invest in new HBO Max spinoff Stuart Fails to Save the Universe: how returnable it is.
By that, I mean the comedy series could easily run for five, 10, or even a million more seasons and not dip in quality or have any continuity issues. Because there’s an infinite number of universes to explore, Stuart Fails to Save the Universe could be taken in any number of zany directions and still make complete sense.
In an age where high-quality TV shows are often being axed before they’ve been in streamable orbit for more than a month, the idea of this alone is refreshing. However, I do have an ulterior motive for wanting Chuck Lorre, Bill Prady and Zak Penn’s latest creation to last for as long as possible.
Latest Videos FromTechRadar
Given enough time, I think that Stuart Fails to Save the Universe could course-correct the biggest mistake that the overarching world it spins off from has ever made, affecting both TBBT and subsequent spinoff Young Sheldon before anybody realized it was a huge issue. Frankly, it’s a grudge I’ve held onto tightly for the last two years (at best).
So when I had the chance to interview the creative trio for their new HBO Max comedy, I wasted no time pitching my story idea for future seasons. I knew it was solid, but I wasn’t expecting them to genuinely consider it.
The pitch: bring George Cooper back to life
Watch On
The biggest mistake TBBT ever made was killing off George Cooper before he was even a realized character in Young Sheldon. In fact, the decision was so poorly judged that Lorre publicly apologized for it after George’s funeral in Young Sheldon season 7.
Let me explain. When we first meet adult Sheldon (Jim Parsons) in TBBT, we learn that his father had died of a heart attack when he was a teenager, and was described as mean, absent, an adulterer and sometimes abusive alcoholic. The less said about him the better, put it that way.
But by the time Young Sheldon took off in 2017, we learned another version of Sheldon’s (Iain Armitage) truth. For most of his childhood in Medford, Texas, George (Lance Barber) did everything he could to try and understand a child that seemed so alien to him. Even George’s alleged affair was disproved, turning out to be Sheldon’s mother Mary (Zoe Perry) in a wig.
George took Sheldon for his first-ever visit to his future academic home CalTech, drove him to NASA’s headquarters just so Sheldon could prove their math was wrong, and let him talk about scientific methods beyond George’s comprehension for hours on end simply because it made Sheldon happy. If you ask me, he was an incredible dad.
But the fact that George would have to die around the time Sheldon was 14 was hanging over our heads from the moment the prequel spinoff was realized. I don’t think anybody expected Young Sheldon to become the gargantuan success that it was, and by the time we got to season 7, the inevitable happened.
Episodes 12-14 of season 7 were dedicated to unpacking George’s death, which happened off-screen while he was coaching football at the local high school. It’s something that destroyed the rest of the Cooper family for good, with follow-up spinoff Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage continuing to help explore how Mary, Missy (Raegan Revord) and Georgie (Montana Jordan) all ended up becoming the people we meet in TBBT years later.
To me, George’s death never actually needed to happen in Young Sheldon. Enough distance had been created between the prequel and TBBT to ignore adult Sheldon’s vision of his childhood altogether, even if it couldn’t be officially rectified. Worst case, they could have waited until season 7 had finished before implying that the death might have happened at some point between Young Sheldon and Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage.
But instead, I sobbed through Mary breaking down after learning her husband had died, and cried my way through his funeral the next week (watching live at 1am UK time, which was a bad decision). I was so distraught and frustrated by the team’s choices that I even wrote George a fake obituary, which actually led to me interviewing Barber himself.
Now that Stuart Fails to Save the Universe has come along, we’ve got a unique chance to change history for the better.
‘The universe you’re looking for is out there — whether it makes it to TV is another question’
Watch On
So here’s the idea: by the time we get many seasons into Stuart Fails to Save the Universe, Stuart will likely know how to control multiverse travel a whole lot better than he does at the moment. Logically, he could then visit a universe where George was never killed and voilà… TBBT‘s costly mistake is put behind us indefinitely.
If Parsons eventually has a cameo in the show too, all the better. There’s no such thing as the “right” version of reality here… any one of them we come across could be where the story anchors down for good. So why shouldn’t a universe fans are actually happy with be chosen in that case? It’s a no-brainer decision, if you ask me.
“Let’s discuss this when we’re doing those future seasons,” Lorre tells me, like I’ve just stormed into the HBO Max head office and requested a legitimate pitch meeting. “One thing you need to know is that we’re not really thinking that far ahead… we’re just trying to solve whatever is right in front of us.”
“We’ll definitely keep your ideas in mind,” Penn follows up with. “There are an infinite number of universes within this universe, so the universe that you’re looking for is going to exist by definition. Whether it makes it to TV is another question.”
“Actually, there’s a mathematical issue with that,” Prady adds. “The fact that there’s an infinite number of universes doesn’t guarantee the existence of a particular universe.”
I tell the trio that this isn’t the positive mindset that I’m looking for, but even as they laugh at my unhinged fan plan delivered with so much gusto that it could have broken even Sheldon’s brain, I’m convinced that I’ve planted an important seed.
Stuart Fails to Save the Universe being renewed for more seasons feels like a given at this point, even if HBO Max hasn’t officially confirmed anything as of writing. But the confidence with which the trio talk about the future suggests that we won’t be done with the multiverse fun after 10 episodes.
So remember these words if you ever see George Cooper have a surprise cameo in the series, and remember who made the retcon magic happen. You’re welcome, in advance.
Follow TechRadar on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our expert news, reviews, and opinion in your feeds.
Read the full article here
