Why you can trust TechRadar
We spend hours testing every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. Find out more about how we test.
Spoilers follow for Emily in Paris season 5.
The minute I heard Emily in Paris season 5 was actually going to be Emily in Rome season 1, I breathed a sigh of relief. After four seasons of Emily (Lily Collins) relentlessly chasing after Gabriel (Lucas Bravo), getting into relationships she shouldn’t and making chaotic decisions at work that accidentally made her a PR success story, we needed a change of scene.
I was desperate for an injection of fresh energy and a feeling that the tried-and-tested format could be revamped in a way that still honors the show’s foundations. But boy, how wrong I was. As the saying goes, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it – and, after watching the entirety of this season, I feel as though I’ve accidentally manifested a crummier version of what we already had.
The worst part is that the show is now inferior because, rather than let the story evolve naturally, the decisions its creative team made instead are, frankly, baffling.
At the end of last season, Emily had met Italian beau Marcello (Eugenio Franceschini) and was ready to take her career to the next level by heading up the new Agence Grateau office in Rome. However, Emily in Paris 5 u-turns on its forebear’s setup by unnecessarily shoehorning Sylvie (Philippine Leroy-Beaulieu), Luc (Bruno Gouery), and Julian (Samuel Arnold) into Emily’s new Italian life. On top of that, Marcello is revealed to be the most repulsive and odious boyfriend since Logan (Matt Czuchry) in Gilmore Girls.
We stay in Rome for less than half of season 5, too, and the diabolical heavy handling of Emily’s time there had me practically sobbing for more Gabriel screentime. How did things change so much during the show’s year-long absence?
Emily in Paris’ core concept has been ruined by bad creative decisions
Watch On
It’s not an easy thing to say, but I genuinely believe the fabric of Emily in Paris season 5 has been torn to shreds by misguided creative decisions. Not just in one area either, but across the board.
Let’s start with Rome. In this season’s premiere, Emily finds out that her season 4 finale dream of heading up Agence Grateau in Rome is nothing more than a sham. Instead, Sylvie decides to dispatch the entire team to Rome and resume her leadership there, which in turn undoes season 4’s career step-up for the show’s protagonist.
Not only is Emily unfulfilled at work (mostly because everyone around her is determined to make her feel inadequate or bulldoze their own dreadful decisions through), but her personal life isn’t going too well, either. The Marcello we met in season 4 is sexy, mysterious and full of possibility. In season 5, though, he’s selfish, flippant, and not overly interested in building a partnership.
By episode five, all of the above has fallen apart. What’s the point in this colossal upheaval if you’re not going to do the best by your main character? In hindsight, it all feels pointless and like a missed opportunity – but we’re only just scratching the surface of those.
For instance, spoilers notwithstanding, best friend Mindy (Ashley Park) has a relationship with someone she shouldn’t. When she lies about it to Emily, the two get in a massive albeit needless fight. With the pair each flitting between two men at any given time, the weary yearning is yet another sign of subpar storyline development.
Only Gabriel can save the day if Emily in Paris season 6 happens
Despite the fact I’ve fully signed off on suspending any belief before I’ve sat down to watch, there’s only so much partner-swapping I can take in a Netflix series like this. Now that Mindy has joined Emily’s romantically indecisive bandwagon in the worst way, investing in any kind of Emily in Paris relationship has never felt so superficial.
The pair’s various romances, nor their friendship, offer anything of value, instead only delving further into shock factor that doesn’t do anyone justice. Emily and Mindy used to have such a wholesome, nourishing relationship that has now dissolved into high school mean-girl meddling. Whatever happened to girls before guys?
The same can be said for Emily and Gabriel, who are in an uneasy lovers-to-friends middle ground, though Bravo hardly has any screentime. It almost feels like the show’s creators know they’ve made a mistake sending Emily to Rome, and are now trying to furiously backpedal by shoehorning Gabriel into scenes that subsequently feel less coherent
Thankfully, there’s potential for Emily in Paris season 6 (which is currently unconfirmed) to set this right. If it happens, I think season 6 would need to be the series’ last – and you’ll see what I mean when you watch this season’s finale. If our end goal of Emily in Paris is for Emily and Gabriel to finally live happily ever after, it has one last shot to land it the proverbial plane.
Basically, I’m just desperately trying to retcon my own past thoughts and get Gabriel back in the thick of Emily’s personal life. We thought a change would work but, after it was butchered, the only way up is for the show’s creative team to give us what I initially thought I didn’t want.
Even Sylvie, Luc, and Julien have veered too far from their start, with Sylvie’s personal life becoming one preposterously stereotypical joke, while Luc and particularly Julian pale into existence. Emily’s not being treated well, either, but at least she looks immaculate.
I promise that there are moments of light-hearted normality amid an otherwise subpar season. For the most part, though, Emily in Paris‘ latest chapter is très mauvais. That said, as long as Marcello never shows his face again, there’s still enough reason for me to see any future seasons out…
Emily in Paris season 5 is out now in full on Netflix, aka one of the world’s best streaming services.
Follow TechRadar on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our expert news, reviews, and opinion in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button!
And of course you can also follow TechRadar on TikTok for news, reviews, unboxings in video form, and get regular updates from us on WhatsApp too.
Read the full article here
